Fuel Dilution Surfaces as Issue
in Some Modern Diesel Engines
AMSOIL has documented
two separate fuel dilution issues in modern diesel applications,
one of which has forced the company to reduce its drain interval
recommendations in a few applications using AMSOIL
Premium CJ-4 Synthetic Diesel Oils (DEO, DME). AMSOIL
recently released a technical
service bulletin detailing that fuel dilution
issue and providing updated recommendations for AMSOIL Premium
Diesel Oils.
Fuel Dilution
Fuel in the oil
reduces the oil's life expectancy and effectiveness. Because
diesel fuel is a natural solvent, fuel dilution in motor oil
causes a decrease in viscosity which may lead to an increase
in engine wear. The following can occur if fuel enters the
crankcase and contaminates the oil:
Reduced oil
viscosity
Reduced oil
film strength
Increased engine
wear (perticularly in the cylinder/ring area)
Increased volatility
Weakened lubricant
detergency
Accelerated
lubricant oxidation
Varnish formation
Acid formation/corrosion
Low oil pressure
The most notable
concern with increased fuel contamination is reduced viscosity
and the effect it has on oil performance.
Issue One: Mechanical Deficiencies
AMSOIL has documented
increasing fuel dilution levels in 2007 and newer Caterpillar
C13 and C15 on-highway engines. Caterpillar has recognized
its fuel dilution problem as noted in a special instruction
titled Determining the Cause of Fuel Dilution of Engine Oil
for On-Highway Engines (C13, C15). The document states that
mechanical deficiencies (i.e. leaking seals on the body or
sleeve of unit injector, cracked body of unit injector, leakage
from the drive shaft seal on the fuel transfer pump, etc...)
are probable causes for fuel dilution.
A tolerable level
of fuel dilution was present in 2007 engines; however, newer
engines exhibit excessively high fuel dilution. Caterpillar
is aware of the relationship between fuel dilution and viscosity
loss and has stated the following:
"Fuel dilution
that is greater than 4 percent will usually cause viscosity
that is less than the specified viscosity grade. For example,
15W-40 oil with 4 percent fuel dilution will have a viscosity
of less than 12.5 cSt."
Even though Caterpillar
realizes that fuel dilution has an adverse effect on viscosity,
the company has not corrected the mechanical deficiencies
that are causing the high fuel dilution rates. Instead, Caterpillar
revised its guidelines for used oil viscosity to "slightly
less than the limits of the SAE viscosity grades." (See
Table 1).
Although AMSOIL
Premium Diesel Oils have shown the ability to maintain integrity
in some fuel dilution conditions, the unresolved mechanical
issues have forced AMSOIL, as a precautionary measure, to
adjust its drain interval recommendations for 2007-present
Caterpillar C13 and C15 on-highway engines.
For all pre-2007
Caterpillar C13 and C15 on-highway engines, the drain interval
has not been affected (3 times the original equipment manufacturer's
recommendations, not to exceed 50,000 miles/600 hours, or
one year).
Issue Two: DPF Regeneration
AMSOIL has also
documented increasing levels of diesel fuel dilution in the
engine oil of 2007-2009 light-duty diesel pickups from all
major vehicle manufacturers. Research indicates that fuel
dilution is increasing due to the use of post-fuel injection
during the diesel particulate filter (DPF) regeneration process.
The issue, however, is not prevalent enough at this point
to warrant an adjustment in the drain interval recommendation
of AMSOIL Premium Diesel Oils.
Regeneration
Process
Current emissions
legislation set by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
mandates that all 2007 and newer on-highway diesel fueled
vehicles come equipped with a DPF. A DPF is generally a honeycomb
like filter positioned in the exhaust stream to collect particulate
matter and soot to prevent it from exiting the vehicle. DPFs
are highly efficient and can usually remove 80-90 percent
of particulate matter from diesel exhaust. When the filter
is near its capacity, soot trapped in the filter is burned,
freeing the plugged media and enabling and enabling the filter
to remain serviceable. The process of burning the residual
matter is termed regeneration and can be either active or
passive.
Active regeneration
uses raw diesel fuel as a combustion source to burn the accumulated
soot and clear the filter. Active regeneration is accomplished
using either in-stream or in-cylinder injection. In-stream
injection systems inject raw diesel fuel directly into the
exhaust stream before it reaches the DPF. In-cylinder injection
systems inject raw diesel fuel directly into the cylinder
on the exhaust stroke. The unburned fuel evaporates and travels
down to the DPF to burn out the soot built up in the filter.
Passive regeneration
requires exhaust gas temperatures of approximately 1100 degrees
Fahrenheit (600 degrees Celsius). These relatively high exhaust
gas temperatures occur naturally in trucks operating under
heavy load and can be used to burn the soot out of DPFs. Passive
regeneration does not increase fuel consumption the way active
regeneration does because, by design, it does not require
the injection of additional fuel to increase exhaust temperatures.
"Less
Costly" Alternative
All class 8 over-the-road
tractors and medium-class applications use active use active
regeneration via in-stream injection. In this method, diesel
fuel used to burn soot in the DPF does not reach the crankcase,
leaving the oil uncontaminated.
Light-duty diesel
pickup manufacturers (Dodge, Ford, GM) have opted for a less
costly in-cylinder injection system. With in-cylinder injection
systems, some raw diesel fuel injected on the exhaust stroke
can wash directly past the rings and into the crankcase, mixing
with the oil. Regular washing of cylinders is a source of
fuel contamination in the crankcase and is not conductive
to long-term engine protection. Use oil analysis results from
2007-2009 light-duty diesel vehicles showed some elevated
fuel dilution, but at tolerable levels.
2010 NOx
Requirements
EPA emission mandates
taking effect in 2010 require the reduction of nitrogen oxides
(NOx) to .2 grams per brake horsepower (g/bhp). To meet this
limit, engine manufacturers will use either selective catalytic
reduction (SCR), NOx absorbers or advanced exhaust gas recirculation
(EGR).
Most over-the-road
truck and tractor manufacturers will use SCR technology, with
International the only major manufacturer to use advanced
EGR technology. Neither system is expected to increase fuel
dilution. Light-duty turbo diesel pickup manufacturers appear
to be moving forward with the relatively new NOx absorber
technology first used by Dodge in its 2007 diesels to meet
2010 NOx requirements. Ford and GM have not yet released vehicles
that meet 2010 NOx limits.
Like DPFs, NOx
absorbers need to be regenerated. However, they require more
fuel to regenerate than DPFs do, which may compound the fuel
dilution problem.
Higher
Fuel Dilution Levels
In Dodge light-duty
turbo diesel pickups, the combined regeneration requirements
of the DPF and NOx absorber technologies are causing fuel
dilution of the engine oil. Model years 2007-2009 Ford and
GM applications also show higher levels of fuel dilution,
which may increase in 2010 emission compliant models if similar
technology is adopted.
Although model
year 2007-2009 light-duty diesels are experiencing higher
fuel dilution than previous model years, regenerating cycles
vary based on service (engines operating in severe service
conditions do not actively regenerate as often as engines
operating in normal service conditions), and some applications
are affected more than others. While not all 2007-2009 light-duty
diesel vehicles develop this problem, fuel contamination can
reduce oil viscosity and decrease film thickness. Other concerns
include significantly reduced fuel economy, accelerated engine
oil oxidation, increased volatility and overfilling of the
oil sump.
AMSOIL
Maintains Drain Interval Recommendations for Premium Diesel
Oils
AMSOIL
Premium Diesel Oils have shown the ability to maintain
integrity in the face of fuel dilution in 2007-2009 light-duty
diesel applications and continue to be recommended for three
times the vehicle manufacturer recommendation, not to exceed
50,000 miles/600 hours or one year. However, it is recommended
that owners of 2007-2009 Dodge, Ford and GM light-duty diesel
vehicles perform regular oil analysis as a precautionary measure.
If oil analysis reveals greater than 5 percent fuel dilution,
AMSOIL recommends changing the oil. The company will continue
to closely monitor this situation, and if deemed necessary,
will adjust recommended drain intervals in these applications.
AMSOIL has documented
increasing levels of fuel contamination (fuel dilution) in
the engine oil of 2007-2008 light-duty Ford, GM and Dodge
diesel pickups, and indications are that 2009-2010 models
are also affected. Research indicates fuel dilution is intensifying
due to the use of in-cylinder post-fuel injection during the
engine's exhaust stroke to regenerate the diesel particulate
filter (DPF). Fuel in the oil reduces the oil's life expectancy
and effectiveness. Because diesel fuel is a natural solvent,
fuel dilution in motor oil causes a decrease in viscosity
which may lead to an increase in engine wear rates.
Although AMSOIL
Premium Diesel Oils have shown the ability to maintain integrity
under fuel dilution conditions, the abnormally high rate and
unknown long-term effects have forced AMSOIL to adjust its
drain interval recommendations as a precautionary measure
in 2007-2010 Dodge 6.7L, Ford 6.4L and GM 6.6L LMM light-duty
turbo-diesel pickups. In these applications, AMSOIL recommends
changing AMSOIL Premium API CJ-4 Synthetic Diesel Oils (DEO,
DME) at the manufacturer-recommended drain interval. Drain
intervals may be extended further with oil analysis.
AMSOIL previously
announced a fuel dilution issue in 2007-2009 on-highway Caterpillar
C13 and C15 engines that forced the company to adjust its
drain interval recommendation in those applications to the
manufacturer-recommended drain interval.
In all other applications,
AMSOIL full synthetic diesel oils are recommended for three
times (3X) the OEM recommendation, not to exceed 50,000 miles/600
hours or one year, whichever comes first, while Synthetic
Blend 15W-40 Heavy Duty Diesel and Gasoline Motor Oil (PCO)
is recommended for the longest OEM recommended drain interval.
Drain intervals may be extended further with oil analysis.
Use This
Form to Get Exclusive Technical Articles and Information
on AMSOIL Products.
Receive valuable
weekly newsletter by email - please complete this form.
Personal contact information
will only be used to provide requested information or
assistance. You will not be enrolled in advertising
or marketing programs and your information will not
be sold.
You will only receive
the email newsletter.
Premium AMSOIL
Synthetic Motor Oils offer the longest drain intervals
on the market, unsurpassed protection and performance that
effectively extends equipment life and improved fuel economy,
saving customers money at the pump and reducing the nation's
dependence on foreign oil.
"AMSOIL
INC. warrants that the use of its lubricants will not cause
mechanical damage to any mechanically sound equipment when
AMSOIL INC. products are used in full compliance with the
company's recommendations and instructions."
AMSOIL
synthetic motor oils are formulated to surpass engine test
specifications, offering protection far greater than competing
motor oils for extended drain intervals. Most synthetic oil
manufacturers make no claim to extended drain intervals, deferring
to the maintenance schedule provided by the vehicle manufacturer.
With its unparalleled oil and warranty program, AMSOIL offers
consumers unprecedented protection and economics.
Another
AMSOIL First
More than 20 years
ago, AMSOIL began using the NOACK volatility test as a comparison
tool and measurement of quality. Back then, nearly every oil
tested side-by-side with AMSOIL synthetic motor oils failed,
and those that passed barely squeaked by. Other oil companies
paid no attention to NOACK results until Ford Motor Company
made it a requirement for service fill oils, validating what
AMSOIL had said all along.
THE
NOACK Volatility Test
The NOACK
Volatility Test determines the evaporation loss
of lubricants in high temperature service. The more
motor oils vaporize, the thicker and heavier they become,
contributing to poor circulation, reduced fuel economy
and increased oil consumption, wear and emissions. AMSOIL
Synthetic Motor Oil resists high temperature volatization
better than other motor oils. AMSOIL Synthetic Motor
Oil maintains peak fuel efficiency and reduces oil consumption
and emissions.
AMSOIL Now An ISO Certified
Manufacturer
AMSOIL recently
received ISO 9001:2000 certification of our Quality Management
System (QMS). NSF International Strategic Registrations is
the registrar that has verified our QMS meets the requirements
of the ISO 9001:2000 standard, the most widely utilized quality
standard throughout the world for quality management systems.
ISO standards are used by over 300,000 companies worldwide
setting rigorous standards for businesses, government and
industry.
ISO 9001:2000
is applicable to any manufacturing and service organization
providing a framework for system development that focuses
on the customer, quality system performance and ongoing improvement.
AMSOIL received ISO 9001:2000 registration under the scope:
synthetic lubricants blending, packaging, and other fulfillment
directly associated with lubricant product.
The ISO
certification puts AMSOIL in line with some of the most efficient
companies in the world. It is further assurance that the products
and services AMSOIL provides will continue to maintain the
high level of quality the company always demanded.
AMSOIL Product Information
Use This
Form to Get Exclusive Technical Articles and Information
on AMSOIL Products.
Receive valuable
weekly newsletter by email - please complete this form.
Personal contact information
will only be used to provide requested information or
assistance. You will not be enrolled in advertising
or marketing programs and your information will not
be sold.
I welcome the opportunity
to work with you personally as your servicing AMSOIL Dealer.
Use the information on this website to contact me. You may
also check out the AMSOIL
Corporate Website for product and business opportunity
information.
If you would like more information
about AMSOIL INC., click one of the links below: